The famous North African port of Ceuta was
the Muslim staging ground for invasions of the Iberian Peninsula in
the 8th century. This Portugese conquest set up further
explorations that led to the discovery of Madiera, the Canary
Islands, the Cape Verdes Islands, and other lands on the west
African coast, all raising the ire of their Iberian neighbors, the
Spaniards. (For more, click here)
Since Spain and Portugal could not be
trusted to settle their differences, Pope Eugenius IV responded to
the crisis by banning all European Christians from the Canary
Islands in order to protect the converted populations. This
was a momentous intervention by a fearless pope. The
Portuguese king's men, who had been raping, plundering and
terrorizing the timid natives of the Canary Islands, pleaded with
the pope to lift his ban ay arguing that agents of the king were
bringing the heathens into Christ's flock. With slightly
different language, these are the same arguments Americans would
use under the banner of Manifest Destiny to claim Indian lands in
the Americas four centuries later.
Eugenius asked his lawyers to come up with
a proper theological response to the Portuguese king's request. (For more on Eugenius, click here)
The lawyers defaulted to Innocent IV's
commentary, arguing that the Pope could direct his agents to
deprive infidels of their property if they refused to yield to the
civilizing influence of Christian missionaries.
His subsequent bull codified these
opinions and authorized the Iberian kings' to convert the
'barbarous natives and control the islands' in the name of the
papal see. As Robert Williams notes in The American
Indian In Western Legal Thought: Discourses on Conquest, the
door to conquest and the subjugation of native peoples in the
Americas, based on Natural law and theocratic responsibility, were
now in place at the threshold of the Age of Discovery.
Eugenius' bull would be repeated several more times, in refined
forms, in the 15th century, bringing Innocent IV's original
commentary into Pope Nicolas V's final decree, Romanus Pontifex,
issued in 1453, which gave the Portuguese crown full title to any
territories in the African region, and gave the king full authority
to "freely and lawfully...make in those territories...any
prohibitions, statutes and decrees whatsoever, even if they be
penal and include the imposition of any kind of tribute." http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11058a.htm
Nicholas V was granting the kings
plenary power to establish and enforce trade monopolies against
other European nations, a nod of approval that legitimated the
Portuguese slave trade on the Gold Coast of Africa under the
pretense of establishing "the higher transcendent goals of unity
and hierarch contained in the pope's Petrine Mandate.
Related People
Related Events
Related Flashpoints